Why Is My Dog Reactive? A Trainer’s Guide to What’s Really Going On (and What Helps)
- Juliana DeWillems
- Oct 8
- 5 min read
If your dog barks, lunges, or growls on walks, you’re not alone. Reactivity is one of the most common challenges dog guardians face, and it can feel overwhelming. The good news? With the right understanding and approach, things can get better.
TL;DR: “Reactivity” isn’t a personality flaw, it’s an emotional response to something in the environment. Common causes include fear, frustration, over-arousal, pain, and health issues. The most effective and kindest path forward is a plan that reduces exposure to triggers, focuses on decompression and enrichment, and teaches your dog alternative behaviors. If you’d like 1:1 help, our team can coach you virtually or in-person (Alexandria, VA). If you want daily guidance you can start today, the DogTraining+ app walks you step-by-step.
What “Reactive” Really Means
When people say “reactive,” they’re usually describing big over-the-top behaviors like barking, lunging, or growling toward dogs, people, bikes, or other triggers. Underneath those big behaviors is an overwhelmed nervous system: your dog’s arousal goes up so quickly that their thinking brain takes a back seat.
Reactivity does not mean your dog is being “dominant” or “stubborn.” It’s often a dog trying to increase distance from something scary (fear-based) or to get to something exciting (frustration-based). Either way, that behavior in response to something in the environment is communication about how they feel and what they need in that moment.
Common Reasons Dogs Become Reactive
1) Fear or Anxiety
Many reactive dogs are saying, “That’s too close!” You’ll often see body language like stiffening, weight shift forward, closed mouth before an outburst, or attempts to avoid before escalation. (If you’re unsure, we can help you decode these signals in a session.)
2) Frustration
Some social, energetic dogs want to greet but feel restrained by the leash. That tension can tip into barking and lunging.
3) Trigger Stacking
Just like us, dogs handle less when they’re tired, stressed, or sore. Several small stressors (poor sleep, construction noise, vet visit) can “stack,” so a normally manageable trigger now sparks a meltdown. Planning recovery days and helping your dog get good sleep matters.
4) Pain or Discomfort
Muscle soreness, arthritis, hip dysplasia, GI upset, allergies, uncomfortable walking gear, or anything else that causes your dog discomfort can increase their reactivity. If your dog’s behavior changed suddenly, loop in your veterinarian immediately and plan to do a deep dive. Unfortunately, a quick physical exam is unlikely to uncover the root cause.
What Doesn’t Help (And Can Make Things Worse)
Punishment and leash corrections. They may suppress the display for a moment but don’t address the underlying reason for the behavior and can increase fear or aggression risk. Evidence-based orgs like the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior recommend reward-based training for both effectiveness and welfare.
Forcing exposure (“flooding”). Parking your dog feet-away from triggers to “get used to it” usually backfires by pushing them over threshold and potentially increasing their fear, worsening the behavior over time.
What Does Help (Trainer-Approved Roadmap)
1) Management: Set Up Easier Wins This Week
Create distance: Choose quieter walking routes, go at off-hours, use visual barriers (cars, hedges), and U-turn before your dog locks on.
Equipment: A well-fitted Y-front harness and a longer leash (8–10 ft where safe) can reduce tension and give room for decompression.
Decompression sniff walks: Sniffing is a genuine nervous-system down-regulator and part of environmental enrichment that can reduce arousal and help your dog calm down before and between triggers. Build these into your routine.
2) Change the Behavior: Thresholds & Reward Alternatives
This is the gold-standard for fear and anxiety-based behaviors.
Thresholds = expose your dog to the trigger below the intensity that causes a reaction (farther away, quieter, briefer). This is This is a critical step, otherwise they will continue to rehearse the unwanted behavior.
Reinforcing alternative behaviors = cue and reward alternative behaviors to the barking and lunging. Literally any other behaviors can be replacement options around triggers: looking calmly, sniffing, turning away, responding to you, walking away. Trainers call this “differential reinforcement”.
In DogTraining+, look for step-by-step lessons about how to encourage and reward new behaviors that can replace the barking and lunging. Prefer a custom plan? Our trainers can map out your dog’s exact thresholds and training steps in a private session.
3) Teach Alternative Skills (When Your Dog Is Under Threshold)
“Look at That” or “Find It” to disengage from triggers
Reorientation to you (automatic check-ins)
Pattern games to create predictability on walks
We layer each of these into your training plan so both you and your dog gain coping tools that are easy to use in real life.
4) Support Recovery Days
After any challenging days where your dog has reactions or experiences more stress than usual, schedule a stress vacation day where you can focus on rest and enrichment for your dog (quiet sniff walks, food puzzles, lots of cuddling). This helps prevent trigger stacking and protects your training gains.
How Our Team Helps (1:1 Coaching)
You don’t have to go at this alone. Our certified team specializes in complex behavior using positive reinforcement. We can help you no matter where you are in the world. You’ll get:
A behavior consultation to go over your dog's behavior history, triggers, thresholds, and management for safety
A written consultation summary with a customized library of resources
Between-session support to keep momentum
Collaboration with other professionals to give you well-rounded support
Want Daily, Bite-Sized Guidance? Meet DogTraining+
If you prefer a self-paced route (or want to support your coaching plan), our app gives you:
Step-by-step reactivity lessons
Information about your reactive dog to help understand and support them better
Attention-building games and enrichment ideas
New content added monthly
When to Loop In Your Vet or a Veterinary Behaviorist
Sudden behavior change
Any concern for pain, GI issues, allergies, anything medical
Extreme behaviors that are hard to manage or prevent
Stress or anxiety that prevents your dog from staying under threshold
When your dog will not eat outside so you cannot do any training around triggers
Medical factors can lower thresholds and complicate behavior, so a team approach is often best.
You’re Not Alone—And Your Dog Isn’t “Bad”
Your dog is communicating the best way they know how. With kind, systematic training and environmental management, most dogs make meaningful progress. That’s exactly what we do every day with clients and inside DogTraining+.
FAQs
Why does my dog react some days and not others?
That’s often trigger stacking—multiple stressors piling up so a tiny thing tips them over threshold. Decompression and recovery days can help to prevent this, as well as learning your dog’s body language and intervening before they tip over.
Will my dog grow out of reactivity?
Most dogs do not simply grow out of reactivity. In fact, without support, reactivity often becomes stronger over time because your dog is practicing the same behavior again and again. The good news is that with the right combination of management, training, and professional guidance, dogs can learn new ways to respond to their triggers. Many guardians see big improvements once they start teaching their dogs alternative behaviors and building in decompression time.
Can reactivity be fully “cured”?
It’s more accurate to think of reactivity as something you manage and improve rather than something you “cure.” Just like people, every dog has their own personality, history, and sensitivities. With consistent, positive reinforcement training, many dogs make huge progress — they may go from daily meltdowns to calmly walking past their old triggers. But expecting a complete “cure” can set unrealistic goals and create frustration. A better mindset is: with the right support, your dog can learn skills to feel calmer, safer, and more successful in the world.
Comments